The public authorities in some CEE countries are considering mandating vaccination requirements for COVID-19. CEE health policy network is now issuing its statement on this matter that is evidence-based and apolitical.

Mandatory vaccination is a health policy that should not be taken lightly. It requires thorough debate supported by the evidence based medical research, high knowledge of the national health care system as well as legal, constitutional, and ethical dimensions. Furthermore, consideration of other alternative approaches (not necessarily health policies) such as imposing further restrictions related to social distancing, campaigns dispelling the myths surrounding vaccination or removing the practical barriers to immunisation should shed light on effectiveness and appropriateness of this policy. Finally, this policy has many expected and possible unexpected consequences that decision makers have to identify and evaluate.

To add to this debate, we have summarized some important points from our field of expertise.
Availability of vaccination: safe and effective vaccines against COVID-19 are available within the 27-nation bloc EU due to common EU approach.
Vaccination uptake: CEE region has significantly lower vaccination uptake (%) than Western or Northern European countries
Death rate in CEE region: Countries with lower vaccination uptake suffer from higher mortality rate by COVID-19.
Population density and the basic reproductive number. The basic reproductive number (R0) is associated with population density, population density continues to have an important impact on disease transmission regardless of transportation accessibility and median income.
Willingness of elder people to get vaccinated against Covid-19: vaccination readiness in Eastern European and Baltic countries is significantly lower than in the other European countries and Israel. The economic situation is the strongest predictor.
Classic barriers to vaccination: A) doubts regarding the safety of vaccines against COVID-19, B) limited access to vaccines C) misleading perception that COVID-19 is not serious threat to one’s personal health.
Weaknesses/Limitations of health care system: inpatient care - limited number of patients that can be treated in intensive care units (number of ventilators and trained doctors) and limited number of medical professionals in general, weak integration of health care (GP-outpatient specialists-hospitals).
Strengths of health care system: ability of medical professionals to be flexible, act quickly on the latest development, endure long hours, provide excellent care despite limited sources.
Socialized health care system in CEE countries: is not demand driven as in the US, and thus its ability to adjust/expand capacities to meet demand is more limited. Hospitals often have to await additional approvals/financial resources from the state.
Ethical dimension: government should be able to mandate anything upon its people unless the absence of such mandate has a direct and negative impact on others.
Different strategies in EU countries: countries in Europe are adopting different strategies in regard to mandatory vaccination. We have identified 3 different groups: 1) Austria (with mandatory vaccination for general population) 2) Italy or France (mandatory vaccination for some professions) 3) Slovenia or the Czech Republic (no mandatory vaccination foreseen).
Aligned with our core values we call primarily for personal responsibility and fair access believing that each individual has a right for fair access to health care services (vaccinated or not).
Furthermore, this statement also contains the results of internal opinion poll distributed among members.

Imagine that as health expert you would be consulted by the Minister of Health of any CEE country with lower vaccination uptake (less than 60%) to give your expert opinion about mandatory vaccination against COVID - 19. Your answer to the following questions would be:
1.  Would you recommend to introduce compulsory vaccination for adults?
  • Yes, for general population (with some exceptions)  3/6
  • Yes, but only for elderly and vulnerable people         0/6
  • Yes, but only for health professionals                        0/6
  • No                                                                              2/6
  • Other answer: yes, but only as a last option             1/6               
  •                         after alternative approaches fail                       
2. Which EU country would you point to in regard to mandatory vaccination?
  • Austria (mandatory vaccination for general population)       3/6
  • Italy, France (mandatory vaccination for some profession)  2/6
  • Slovenia, Czechia (no mandatory vaccination foreseen)     1/6
  • Other answer:…………………………………                        0/6
Results from internal opinion poll distributed among CEE HPN members clearly show that mandatory vaccination against COVID-19 is an issue that is not at all straight forward. This conclusion from opinion poll calls for continuing debate between health experts.

To read the full version with refrences click here.
© 2023 Central & East European Health Policy Network